Review of A Place of Execution - Book and TV Series

I came across the novel, A Place of Execution, while searching for the top 10 women fiction writers in the mystery/thriller genre. Val McDermid's name must have appeared in nine out of 10 those lists.

I read the back covers and reviews of most of her novels and got this one because I was curious about the concept of two storylines.

So, here is my review of A Place of Execution (book and TV series).

Book Review: A Place of Execution by Val McDermid

The novel begins with the disappearance of a young girl, Alison Carter, in the 1960s. The mystery unfolds through the perspective of Detective Chief Inspector Hill, who is tasked with solving the case. As Hill delves deeper into the investigation, secrets about the town and its residents are revealed, and what initially seems like a straightforward case becomes increasingly complex.

What I particularly appreciated about McDermid’s writing is her skill in building suspense. The novel’s pace is deliberate, allowing the reader to become fully engrossed in the world she creates. McDermid doesn’t rush the investigation, instead letting the story unfold slowly, with layers of tension constantly building. The characters, especially Hill, are multi-dimensional and complex, making them feel real. As Hill uncovers more about the people involved in the case, it’s clear that everyone has something to hide.

The novel is structured in a way that shifts between timelines, gradually revealing more about the past, the investigation, and the consequences of Hill’s actions. McDermid does an excellent job of weaving together these timelines, allowing the reader to piece together the mystery in a way that feels satisfying yet unpredictable.

Ultimately, A Place of Execution is a rich, atmospheric novel that keeps you guessing until the very end. McDermid’s writing is sharp and vivid, and the characters are well-developed. The book doesn’t just rely on twists to entertain—it's a reflection on the complexities of human nature, morality, and the impact of secrets.

TV Series Review: A Place of Execution

The TV series adaptation of A Place of Execution attempts to capture the essence of Val McDermid’s novel, but while it’s an intriguing watch, it doesn't quite match the depth of the book. The six-part miniseries stars a talented cast, with the ever-reliable Lee Ingleby playing the role of Detective Chief Inspector Hill. The show does an admirable job of maintaining the atmosphere of the novel, with its hauntingly eerie countryside setting.

However, the series struggles to achieve the same level of suspense as the book. While the visual medium provides its own strengths—such as the ability to showcase the landscape and the eerie setting—it doesn’t allow for the same psychological depth that the novel does. The internal conflicts and the intricacies of the characters’ personalities, which are explored in great detail in the book, are only hinted at here.

The pacing in the TV adaptation is faster, which works in some ways, but also detracts from the slow-burn tension that McDermid so masterfully builds in the novel. The twists and turns of the plot feel a bit more predictable in the series, and there’s less time for the audience to fully absorb the emotional weight of the story.

The series also leaves out some of the novel’s subtler moments and backstories, which results in a more streamlined narrative. While the performances are strong and the show remains a solid mystery, it doesn’t evoke the same level of emotional engagement or intellectual satisfaction that the book offers.

Comparison: Book vs TV Series

Comparing the book and the TV series, it’s clear that the novel provides a more nuanced and rich experience. Val McDermid’s writing gives readers the opportunity to delve deeply into the psychological aspects of the case. The multiple timelines in the book allow the story to unfold in a way that is both intricate and satisfying, revealing crucial details about the characters and the case in layers.

In contrast, the TV series is limited by time and visual storytelling. While it captures the core elements of the mystery, it misses some of the complexity that makes the book so compelling. The pacing in the show is much quicker, and as a result, the twists and turns of the plot don’t carry the same weight. The characters also feel somewhat reduced in the TV version, with less room for exploration of their deeper motivations and emotions.

Another key difference is the emotional depth. The book offers a more profound exploration of morality, secrets, and the consequences of actions, whereas the TV show, despite being entertaining, doesn’t dive as deeply into these themes. The setting, which plays an important role in the book, is well-realized in the series, but doesn’t feel as integral to the story.

In conclusion, the book provides a far more rewarding experience, offering a layered, tense narrative that lingers long after the final page. The TV series is still worth watching for fans of the mystery genre, but it lacks the depth and complexity of the novel.

Final Thoughts

Val Mcdermid's “A Place of Execution” is a masterful crime novel, and despite the TV series adaptation’s best efforts, it cannot quite match the depth of the book. The novel’s slow build up, intricate plotting, and psychological complexity make it a standout in the crime fiction genre.

If you enjoyed the TV series, I highly recommend reading the book to experience the full, unabridged mystery. What did you think of the adaptation? Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments below!

Click the heart button to the bottom right if you liked the blog post.

Subscribe (button to the top right) to get notified about new blog posts and other updates.