Book Review of Magpie Murders, by Anthony Horowitz

I came across this book after I finished writing my second novel (probably some time before that). I wanted to find if there were novels with similar storyline. (I won't tell if or how many novels I found.)

But this novel was right up there with the best. This is an intriguing novel and requires your total attention while reading.

Here is my review of Magpie Murders, by Anthony Horowitz. There is also a TV Series (2022). I haven't watched it though.

Book Review of Magpie Murders

The story begins with Susan Ryeland, a book editor, who receives the latest manuscript from her most popular author, Alan Conway. At first, she believes she is just reading another entry in Conway’s detective series featuring Atticus Pünd, but soon she realizes the manuscript contains more than just fiction.

The opening pulled me in immediately because Horowitz knows how to create curiosity with every sentence. I could feel myself slipping into that world of old-fashioned detective fiction, filled with English villages, eccentric characters, and dark secrets hiding beneath polite surfaces.

However, the real intrigue came when Susan discovered something shocking—the ending of the manuscript was missing, and soon after, Conway himself was found dead. From that moment, I understood that I wasn’t only reading a mystery novel, but a story about how mysteries themselves are created and experienced.

One of the most brilliant things about Magpie Murders is its book-within-a-book structure, which works on multiple levels at once. In the inner story, we follow Atticus Pünd, a detective clearly inspired by Hercule Poirot, as he investigates a suspicious death in a small English village. This section is written in a Golden Age detective style, full of clever red herrings, subtle clues, and dramatic confrontations. It feels like a lost Agatha Christie novel, and for anyone who loves that classic style, it is pure enjoyment.

Then we shift back to Susan’s world, which is more modern, cynical, and layered with tension. Her investigation into Alan Conway’s death begins to echo the fictional mystery she was editing, and suddenly I found myself comparing both narratives, looking for connections.

Horowitz uses this clever device to comment on storytelling, the publishing world, and the way authors hide pieces of themselves in their writing. As a reader, I felt constantly challenged to solve not just one puzzle, but two interlocked ones, which made the reading experience unique and deeply rewarding.

What stood out for me most while reading was how Horowitz used the novel to explore bigger themes about art, fiction, and truth.

Susan Ryeland, as an editor, is both part of the mystery and also a guide to the reader, as she explains how detective novels work. Through her perspective, I got to see how writers shape stories, why endings matter, and how real life can often be just as puzzling as fiction.

Alan Conway, the fictional author, is also a fascinating character, though we see him mostly through the eyes of others. He is brilliant but bitter, talented but arrogant, and clearly modeled on aspects of his characters on people he disliked in real life.

This blurred line between fiction and reality becomes one of the central threads of the book. Atticus Pünd himself, though a fictional detective within a fictional story, feels like a fully realized character who commands respect and attention.

Stylistically, Horowitz balances homage and innovation with remarkable skill. The Pünd sections feel like vintage detective stories, while Susan’s narrative feels contemporary and self-aware. The language is sharp, but never overwhelming, the pacing careful but never dull. I found myself reading slowly, savoring the details, while also wanting to race ahead to uncover the truth.

By the time I reached the final chapters of Magpie Murders, I realized I had been on a literary roller coaster that was as much about storytelling as it was about solving crimes.

Horowitz manages to keep the suspense alive until the very end, and when the pieces finally clicked together, I felt both surprised and satisfied. It reminded me why I love mystery novels—they make you feel clever, they make you doubt yourself, and they remind you that answers are always hidden in plain sight.

The book also left me reflecting on the relationship between authors and readers. As Susan pieced together Conway’s secrets, I thought about how every book is a conversation between a writer and an audience.

Horowitz makes that conversation explicit, and it gives the story a richness beyond the usual whodunit formula. The experience was not only entertaining, but also intellectually stimulating, which is rare in mystery fiction today.

Final Thoughts

Magpie Murders is more than just a murder mystery—it is a puzzle box of layered storytelling, clever satire, and thoughtful commentary on writing itself. Anthony Horowitz has crafted a novel that works both as a homage to Golden Age detective fiction and as a modern reinvention of the genre.

If you enjoy mysteries that make you think as well as entertain you, this book is an excellent choice. It will keep you guessing, questioning, and reflecting long after you close the final page.

Have you read Magpie Murders? Did you prefer Atticus Pünd’s classic puzzle or Susan Ryeland’s modern investigation? Share your thoughts in the comments below—I’d love to hear your perspective.

Leave comments below if you found the blog post interesting.

Like and share to people who you think would be interested in this blog post

Subscribe (button to the top right) to get notified about new blog posts and other updates.